What is Review in Criminal Law in Delft?
Review is an extraordinary legal remedy available after a decision has become final, including in cases before the court in Delft. Under Article 457 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CCP), the Supreme Court may review a final judgment if new facts or evidence emerge that demonstrate the innocence of the convicted person or establish criminal liability in a previous acquittal. In the Delft region, given its proximity to the District Court of The Hague (Rotterdam team), this remedy is occasionally applied in local criminal cases involving the TU Delft or incidents in the historic city center.
This remedy is strictly regulated to safeguard legal certainty, particularly in a university city like Delft where complex cases such as theft or drug offenses frequently occur. A request for review must contain concrete and new evidence, such as a false witness statement from the Delft Market or DNA material that was previously unavailable due to limited forensic facilities. The procedure begins at the Supreme Court, which decides whether a review will take place after referral from the local court.
Conditions and Procedure in the Delft Context
Key conditions are that the evidence could not have been known earlier and directly impacts the judgment, for example, in a review case concerning an alleged offense near Delft Station. The procedure consists of two phases: the granting of the request and a new substantive hearing at the district court. Successful reviews may result in acquittal, sentence reduction, or a new sentence, with consideration for local victims in the municipality of Delft.
Review illustrates that finality is not absolute but provides a safety net against miscarriages of justice in Delft, where the Haaglanden Police are often involved. In practice, only a few cases lead to review each year, such as a recent case involving a wrongful conviction in the city center, underscoring its exceptional nature.
Consequences of Review for Residents of Delft
Following a review, the enforcement of the sentence may be suspended, with direct implications for local detainees in the region. Convicted individuals are entitled to compensation if wrongfully detained, for example, for lost income among TU Delft students or entrepreneurs. This mechanism strengthens confidence in the criminal justice system in Delft and the surrounding area.
(Word count: 312)